Wikipedia Tightens Submission RulesI find it kind of ironic that this news story popped up when I logged onto Yahoo today. It is ironic because, just last week, I was engaged with several of my colleagues in a heated discussion about open content, blogs, wikis, and their potential in the classroom. The topic was brought up by a guest who visited our department for the day, Dr. David Wiley from Utah State University, who is is ... to put lightly ... a supporter of open access to information.
Dr. Wiley described wikis, with wikipedia as his example, as a massive, peer-reviewed information repository. It is a space where information can easily be found, and more importantly, be updated and/or changed by anyone who wants to. The deletion of incorrect information or spam can be done by any user who happens along and sees something that needs fixing, so it is a self-policed system.
It may be an interesting source of information, but I still have some problems with using Wikipedia as an information source.
First of all, I just don't think the content is reliable. Spam messages are easily spotted and fixed, as well as blatant erroneous statements, but how about more subversive misinformation? As the article above states, personal attacks can be made into "fact," and really, who knows enough to correct a person's biography. In terms of education, I would not let my students cite Wikipedia. While description of the bombing of Pearl Harbor found by my student may be correct (ie, have correct dates, places, times, actions, and participants) 99 days out of 100, what if the information is accessed on that one day where it has been altered? Also, how can my student truly ever quote a source when, within the next minute, the content has changed? I guess citations would need specific dates and times to work with a wiki, but then, who's the author that would be cited?
This question leads me to one other major concern I have about wikis ... responsibility. If I publish an encyclopedia, then I'm responsible for the content within. If I post on a wikipedia, then I'm essentially anonymous. The only responsibility I have to provide correct information is an ethical one. In an ideal situation, freedom of information provided almost limitless opportunities to the population. The real world, however, is not ready for free access and modification of information. In order for such a system to truly succeed, the population will need to be responsible consumers of information as well as providers, and with comparatively limited venues of information (newspapers, television, books, and teachers), there are already too many people who blindly accept whatever they read, see, or are told.