The advertising blitz for
War of the Worlds has been massive. Super Bowl and theatrical teasers gave just a hint of the special effects to expect. Tom Cruise has been on seemingly every talk show in the country the last few weeks, though he has done more inane babbling about scientology and his beau Katie Holmes than about his new film. Science fiction fans have been awaiting the
War of the Worlds remake with guarded to unbridled optimism, seeing as the original 1953 film definitely left some chances for improvement in both the plot and special effects areas and a very competent director in Stephen Spielberg would be at the helm of the remake. It is unfortunate that a movie with so much promise is so badly hobbled by its updated plot and scripting.
The premise of the
War of the Worlds is quite simple. A voiceover, performed by Morgan Freeman (who does not appear in the movie), starts off the film with the statement that aliens have watched our world with envious eyes, planning their actions. The accompanying special effects foreshadow the ending to anyone familiar at all with H.G. Well's original story, Orson Welles's radio play, or the 1953 film. The audience is then introduced to Ray Ferrier (Tom Cruise), the proverbial hard-lifed everyman who is a dock worker and spends his free time working on cars and acting bitter about his divorce. When his kids are dropped off for the weekend, he acts indifferently towards them, though it is quite obvious that he gets along better with his 10 year old daughter Rachel (Dakota Fanning) than his 16 year old teenage son Robbie (Justin Chatwin) who suffers from the usual I'm-a-teenager-and-am-not-going-to-listen-to-you-no-matter-what-horrible-things-are-going-on attitude that can be found in movies trying to be "real" about the relationships between teens and their parents. Once the troublesome family dynamic has been introduced, the plot swings into motion, and mysterious lightning storms around the world start resulting in earthquakes and EMP shockwaves that wipe out all electronic devices. One of these storms of course happens in Ray's neighborhood, and he witnesses first hand the terrifying truth of the situation when a gigantic tripod-shaped machine emerges from the ground and starts vaporizing the fleeing people, leaving only their clothes to artistically flutter to the ground. The rest of the film centers on Ray trying to get his daughter and son to Boston so that the kids can be with their mother and he would no longer have to be responsible for them. The journey is, of course, fraught with peril from both humans and aliens, and the pacing is quick for the most part.
The problem with the film, as I mentioned earlier, is that the plot and script just don't work. Many of the most serious logical problems are caused by the decision of the filmmakers to change the arrival of the aliens. In the original story, the aliens arrived appearing as falling meteors, smashing into the earth. In this version, their machines were evidently buried deep beneath the ground thousands (or millions) of years ago. Conveniently enough, this is explained by a news crew's video tape containing a close-up of the lightning strikes that show a pod entering the earth, presumably to man the machines buried there. The presence of the video tape itself is certainly a convenient yet problematic plot point considering that a)the lightning strikes were short and focused on a single spot ... what are the odds that a news crew happened to be exactly at the point of impact b) EMP supposedly knocked out all electrical circuits because of the lightning (at one point Ray is shown tapping his now defunct watch), yet the video camera continues recording unmolested and c) the van and equipment of the news crew also works, allowing them to show their tape to Ray, who just happened to be passing by. There is also, of course, the question as to why the aliens have waited so long to make their attack. Considering their machines were buried long before humans built on top of them (a character in the movie suggests a million years ago), why the elaborate planning? Humans could have easily been wiped out with no resistance when the aliens originally arrived ... but they waited for us to develop? This huge time investment also makes the ending even more questionable ... without spoiling it, let me just say that wouldn't such a time frame, with aliens already having landed on earth, have allowed them time for deep analysis of the world they wished to conquer? I also have a problem with Ray acting over-protective of his kids, though he constantly makes decisions that put them into danger, such as boarding a ferry when the landing is under attack and heading for a destination that is assuredly also a major target.
On the acting side, Tom Cruise does a passable job as a protective father, though I don't buy him as an "everyman" ... give me Tom Hanks any day. Ever since
Top Gun Tom Cruise has been in cocky mode, and this film is no exception. Dakota Fanning's sole purpose of the film seems to be screaming, something she does any time an inopportune moment presents itself. She is of course the first person to see any event off in the distance (she must have eyes like a hawk), and Spielberg constantly zooms into her face for a reaction shot at the start of about every action sequence. Justin Chatwin plays Robbie's teen angst well, though to no fault of his own, it seems really petty, unnecessary, and annoying in a time of crisis (which is probably the point). Tim Robbins has a small, throw away role as a survivalist who's sole purpose is to demonstrate to the audience how far Ray is willing to go to protect his daughter. Quite frankly, the actions of all of these characters are so stupid at times that Darwin would agree with me that their chance of survival should be nil.
The special effects are, of course, very good. There are also several beautiful/artistic/chilling shots to be found, making me wish that the care taken for the setup of those shots would have been used in the rest of the movie in the hope that it wouldn't be so pulpy. All in all, Spielberg has created an action movie with some visually striking moments and a script that thinks it is smarter than what it really is. In the end, too many things are left unexplained or seem to occur for no reason, and the conclusion of the events surrounding Ray's family seems overly happy for a movie in which millions of people have been slaughtered in an attempted extermination of the human race. The script isn't
Independence Day dumb, but it tries its best to be so, though at least
Independence Day knew enough not to take itself so seriously. There are just too many major plot holes for Spielberg's
War of the Worlds to be considered smart science fiction, which in my book just heaps it into the pile of disposable summer action movies ... and this makes the film even worse, because it tries to be something that it is not ... you know ... good.
Rating: 5/10