Monday, June 06, 2005

There's a catch, and it's Catch-22 ....

I was digging through my file archives this morning and ran across a paper that I wrote for ENGL 412N: The Historical Novel maybe 3 years ago. This was one of my favorite papers to write (though perhaps not one of my better efforts) because it was on one of my favorite novels, Catch-22.

The Sanity of Insanity: Mind-bending Duality in Catch-22

During the United States Civil War, General William Tecumseh summed up the entire conflict by saying “War is hell.” This phrase to rings true, as the constant pressure of immediate death would seem to be enough to crack the mental toughness of even the most devoted soldier. War represents the pinnacle of peril for one’s body, and a mind having to face the cold and brutal reality of unnatural death is forced into a schism of what has become “right” and what used to be right. In “normal” society, killing is frowned upon, and putting oneself in immediate mortal peril is an occurrence that can usually be avoided. In war, however, common men are forced to hurl themselves into harm’s way for the express intent of killing another behind the mantra of peace. With so many contradictions and flip-flopped attitudes present during the wartime conditions, it is not surprising that Joseph Heller’s Catch-22 finds its characters embroiled in utter turmoil and insanity over confusing, yet sound, circular logic and duality.

Joseph Yossarian is a soldier trapped in the middle of World War II who, with each flight into hostile territory, becomes more and more certain that he is going to be killed. He comes to resent the commanding officers that refuse to ground him and send someone else out in his place, as the fact “that men would die was a matter of necessity; which men would die, though, was a matter of circumstance, and Yossarian was willing to be the victim of anything but circumstance” (Catch-22 69). Though he is urged to continue flying for the good of his country, he cannot get past the realization that “it doesn’t make a damned bit of difference who wins the war to someone who’s dead” (127). While Yossarian’s critical thinking about war makes him aware of his insignificance, the problem with his attitude is that the military would fall apart if a large number of soldiers felt the same way. Thus, he is labeled as being anti-American and crazy for wanting to disobey orders, though he is not crazy enough to be sent home, a fact that Yossarian finds extremely irritating.

Yossarian is not the only man in his squadron considered to be crazy, however. McWatt is described as “the craziest combat man of them all probably, because he was perfectly sane and still did not mind the war” (61). In fact, Doc Daneeka thinks that every single person who flies into combat is nuts, and even though it is his job to ground unfit pilots, he is not allowed to until they ask. This is where Catch-22 swings into full effect, though, as Yossarian, McWatt, Orr, or any of the other airmen “would be crazy to fly more missions and sane if [they] didn’t, but if [they were] sane, [they] had to fly them. If [they] flew them [they were] crazy and didn’t have to; but if [they] didn’t want to [they] were sane and had to” (47). The circular logic that comprises Catch-22 embodies the battle between duty and self-preservation, as the people who want to be flying missions are not mentally stable enough to do it, while those who do not want the job are worried more about themselves than the mission. A clear example of this idea is McWatt, who does not mind flying missions, but ends up killing Kid Sampson by performing a foolish, crazy stunt. Whether the airmen want to fly missions or not, though, they know that they are in the war for its duration or their death, as they will never meet the ever increasing quota of missions as assigned by Colonel Cathcart.

From the start of the novel, there is a clear separation in attitudes between the commanding officers such as Cathcart, who issue their orders from a seat of comfort well away from the front lines. The combat men, on the other hand, must act on the orders given to them without question, and are expected to sacrifice their life, if need be, in order to complete their mission. Each group considers the other to be insane, as they face two different sides of the reality of war. The commanders perform their jobs with extreme conviction, knowing that their decisions will either help the war effort or help themselves receive a promotion. Colonel Cathcart, for example, “had courage and never hesitated to volunteer his men for any target available. No target was too difficult for his group to attack” (57). As it turns out, Cathcart is motivated just as much by self-preservation as Yossarian, but because he does not actually place himself in mortal danger, Cathcart’s preservation lands him squarely into a social Catch-22. Cathcart keeps raising the number of missions his men have to fly in order to impress his superiors by how many missions he can squeeze out of his squadron, yet once the number of missions required has risen so high that everyone has achieved the 50 required for other squadrons, Cathcart cannot “possibly requisition so many inexperienced replacement crews at one time without cause an investigation. He’s caught in his own trap” (451). Thus, Cathcart must keep all of his men in the air, risking their life, in order to avoid stirring up controversy.

To combat what he sees as Cathcart’s reckless desire for his death, Yossarian is finally driven to the point where he refuses to fly any more missions, knowing that sooner or later, he will be shot down when the German gunners “take their aim and pull their triggers or lanyards or switches or whatever the hell they did pull when they wanted to kill people they didn’t know” (30). Because of this paranoia, Yossarian becomes the insane image of a man walking backwards with a gun on his hip, skittish at any sound, afraid that someone will jump him and force him back into the air. The duality of the situation is that by trying to survive, he is hurting his country, as missions are not being flown and the men are losing morale. On the other hand, Yossarian has repeatedly flown the number of missions he has had to, only to have that number raised beyond his grasp once he has reached it. Thus, Yossarian “was jeopardizing his traditional rights of freedom and independence by daring to exercise them” (414). Though it may seem odd, the argument can be made that Yossarian endangers the United States by utilizing the rights that he supposed to be fighting to protect. After all, soldiers are to shut up and follow orders, making extra sure not to let their thoughts get into the way.

Whether or not Yossarian is a threat to the national security of the Untied States, it is clear that he and his comrades are caught in an impossible situation when looked at from a logical perspective. The line between insanity and sanity is blurred, as both mental states result in having to go into combat. The worst facet of the entire situation, though, is that no one takes personal responsibility for their actions until Yossarian decides to question authority and not go on missions. After all, why take the blame for another person’s life or death when the blame can be attributed to an unwritten law: Catch-22.

2 comments:

C the Maven said...

First off : this paper of yours has made me want to read the book.

Secondly : you're a great writer. I like your "voice." It's very you. Not to mention your word choice. And, well, the most important aspect: you're very good at constructing a clear and solid thesis.

Thirdly: Teach me how to write like that!! It's a real skill that you have. Treasure it. :)

Chris Mong said...

Thanks Cthemaven! I would recommend this book ... it may be about war, but believe me, it doesn't make it sound glorious.