Saturday, November 19, 2005

My review: Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire

The tone of Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire is dark, dark, dark, and is set in the opening scene. Within the first two minutes of the film there is a murder. This is the first "on screen" killing of the series (not counting Professor Quirrell or flashback images of Harry's parents, of course), and as fans know, it will not be the last of the series, or the movie for that matter. Goblet of Fire serves as the "middle" movie of the series, the fourth out of seven, and it is also completes the transition that Prisoner of Azkaban started for placing the characters in darker, more adult situations.

The movie starts out with Harry joining Hermione and the Weasleys at the Quidditch World Cup. After escaping an attack by Lord Voldemort's followers, the Death Eaters, Harry and his friends find themselves back at Hogwarts. Joining them this year are the students of two other schools, as Hogwarts is hosting a competition called the Tri-Wizard tournament, in which one champion from each school is chosen to compete for eternal glory. Harry is too young to enter his name into the contest, which makes it only slightly more surprising when his name is selected as the unexpected fourth contestant. Harry, along with Cedric Diggory, Fleur Delacroix, and Viktor Krum, find themselves competing in three dangerous tasks to determine the winner. Other plot points include the new Defense Against the Dark Arts teacher, Alastor "Mad Eye" Moody, a spat between Harry and Ron, and the traditional adolescent trials of shy, young men trying to ask girls to a dance.

Even though Goblet of Fire is the second longest Harry Potter movie, clocking in at just over two and a half hours (sans credits), it feels like the shortest. Goblet of Fire is, so far, the second longest book in the series (eclipsed only by book 5, Order of the Phoenix), and even with major excising of subplots and minor characters, the break-neck speed of the movie is necessary just to get through everything. The plot never truly feels rushed, however, and there is such a mix of danger, excitement, and humor throughout that the audience is kept on their toes. I suppose purists will again be upset about the missing or changed plot points, but I think most of them were clever and necessary to keep any kind of momentum. The major ones are:
  • No Dursleys, which is only a small sore point since this story had one of their best scenes where the Weasleys attempt to visit using the fireplace.
  • There is an added person in Harry's dream about Voldemort and Wormtail and their murder of Frank Bryce
  • No Winky, Dobby, or Ludo Bagman
  • No S.P.E.W. (Hermione's house-elf club) ... thank goodness
  • Rita Skeeter is a bit part with her plot excised except for the fact that she's a trashy reporter
  • Harry's task with the dragon is made more "dramatic"
  • There is no sense of Harry practicing hard for his tasks
  • Percy is not shown as Barty Crouch's lapdog
  • Surprisingly, there is no mention by Dumbledore at the end to get into contact with the old crew (ie, members of the next film's Order of the Phoenix)
Even with these changes, some of my favorite scenes are present and accounted for. I love the scene where Moody demonstrates the "Unforgivable Curses." I also love the scene with Malfoy, the amazing dancing ferret. In Prisoner of Azkaban, I was disappointed with some of the plot exclusions (like the origins of the Marauder's Map) because they seemed like they would have been easy to add. I had no similar sense of disappointment with Goblet of Fire.

On the acting front, let me just say that I hope that they are able to keep all of the main characters for the rest of the series. It is somewhat comforting to see the same people in each movie, and the continuity allows the viewers some of the same feelings as the readers ... resuming a story with old friends. Daniel Radcliff is actually called on to act a bit as Harry in this installment, and for the most part, does a very good job. Emma Watson's Hermione is as charming as ever, and Rupert Grint's Ron is given a bit more range than just reacting to whatever Harry and Hermione do. Michael Gambon's Dumbledore is a bit more emotional and frightening in this installment, and he has some truly surprising reactions (like shoving Harry into a wall). Brendan Gleeson does a good job as the unpredictable Moody. Most of the other adult actors are relegated to the background, but all turn in good performances. Alan Rickman's Snape steals most of the scenes that he is in even though he only gets to speak about two lines in the entire movie. About the only acting disappointment I had was Ralph Fiennes's Voldemort because he didn't seem menacing enough, though that might have been because his dialogue was quick (I'd imagine Voldemort being much more deliberate).

Director Mike Newell is the first British director of the series (he turned down opportunity to direct the first movie), and he builds off of Alfonso Cuaron's darker vision of Hogwarts. Newell's direction is just as stylish and artistic as Cuaron's except that it doesn't call attention to itself. Cuaron's direction seemed to scream "Look at me!" with long fade-ins and outs, while Newell's choices seem much less heavy-handed.

All-in-all, Goblet of Fire is a great addition to the series, and it makes me wish that Newell would agree to do the next film, though that job has been given to another Brit, David Yates. The movie moves quickly and was extremely satisfying for me, which is a an accomplishment considering it is my favorite book of the series so far. It is a promising start to the home-stretch of the series, and it is a good sign that Warner Bros. did not try to dilute the content to escape the PG-13 rating that has been assigned to the film. Believe me, this IS a PG-13 movie. It includes fierce action sequences, a bit of language, a hint of romance, and scary scenes, so young kids will likely be frightened, even if they have already read the story. Next up is Order of the Phoenix, my least-favorite entry of the series, and I eagerly await it.

Rating: 8/10

No comments: