Sunday, July 23, 2006

My review: Pirates of the Caribbean 2

Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest is the inevitable follow up to the surprisingly successful Pirates of the Caribbean: Curse of the Black Pearl. It was Johnny Depp's performance that stood out in the original (he was even nominated for an Academy Award), meaning that the sequel must aspire to offer even more of the weird for the sake of weird Captain Jack Sparrow.

The plot of the film is fairly simple, but for some reason takes about an hour to set up. Will Turner (Orlando Bloom) and Elizabeth Swann (Keira Knightley) have their wedding day interrupted by Lord Beckett, who on behalf of the East India Trading Company, has warrants for the arrest and execution of both Will and Elizabeth for the part they played at the end of the first film in the release of Captain Jack. Of course, Beckett has an ulterior motive. He charges Will with a quest ... find and retrieve Jack's compass. Off Will goes to find the wily Captain Jack, and Elizabeth, not content to stay in her cell, manages to escape and set after Will. Jack, on the other hand, is facing problems with the monster Davey Jones, to whom he had promised his soul 13 years ago in exchange for being captain on the Black Pearl.

The main problem with this movie is the amount of characters it tries to keep track of. All three of the returning major characters (Jack, Will, Elizabeth) spend a lot of screen time apart, meaning the narrative flow is constantly being broken to check up on what is happening elsewhere in the story. Throw in new characters, including Davey Jones and Will's father Bootstrap Bill, as well as the major supporting cast from the first movie like Mr. Gibbs, and suddenly, there's a lot people to take care of in the story that is meant to be a light-hearted action film. This also results in a 2.5 hour running length that, at least to me, felt about 20-30 minutes too long. Too many times does the camera linger on unnecessary shots in an effort to set the mood or to display Jack's weirdness. OK ... we get it.

The acting is about what you would expect. Depp's Sparrow is fine, though the act that was fresh in the first movie starts to wear thin here. Bloom actually seems to have improved his acting since the first movie (I guess more movies and working with directors like Ridley Scott will do that). Knightly does an OK job with Elizabeth, but seems to be hamming her part more now then she did in the first film. The special effects are first rate, and it is obvious that this was a very expensive production.

In case you didn't know, this film is open-ended, with the sequel already mostly filmed. Assuming that the third movie offers a run-time similar to the first two, at roughly nine hours of film, I believe that makes the movie trilogy clock-in at approximately one hour of movie per minute of the Walt Disney World ride that inspired the movie. Now, Disney purists will tell me that the real Pirates ride is at DisneyLand and offers a much longer experience than the mini-version at Disney World ... but I think you get my point. ;)

Quote to remember: You know, these clothes do not flatter you at all. It should be a dress or nothing. I happen to have no dress in my cabin. -- Jack Sparrow to Elizabeth

Rating: 6/10

PS - I managed to see this movie in digital projection, and I must say, the colors and brightness were great. I thought I noticed a little bit of artifacting, but overall, I would probably choose DLP again if I had the chance. No scratches. No cigarette burns. No film jumps. I can definitely appreciate a digital experience.

PPS - This film is rated PG-13 and definitely earns the rating. Not only is the movie insanely long for younger viewers, but there are quite a few scary images or gross scenes. I noticed quite a few younger children at the screening I attended (ages 4-7) and was thinking ... why?

No comments: