I think that for the purposes of this review, it is important for me to be upfront about my knowledge of Watchmen. Having heard that it is a great graphic novel, I picked it up over last summer to read, went through it fairly quickly, and have not touched it since then. I was fairly impressed about the complexity of the characters and story, but not blown away. Going into this film, I remembered broad strokes of the plot and the simplest descriptions of the characters but, to be honest, could not give you a list of character names beyond Dr. Manhattan, Rorschach, and the Comedian.
From that perspective, I was fairly impressed with the movie adaptation of Watchman. Directed by Zach "slo mo" Snyder, it follows The Dark Knight down the path of brooding, extremely dark super-hero movies. Sure, Spiderman gave us a broody "real problems" Peter Parker, but Parker's based-on-today's world feels much less real than the alternate reality of the Watchmen's world. In fact, I think that the opening credits, set to Bob Dylan's "The Times They Are A-Changin'", may be one of the most effective I can recall when it comes to situating the audience in the world of the movie and efficiently setting up back-story.
For the great unwashed who are new to the world of Watchmen, take warning: this movie (less so than the book, but even still) is more drama and back-story than the action movie that is being advertised. In fact, those with short attention spans or those not willing to invest effort will soon be lost. The movie starts out quickly with the brutal murder of a man who is soon identified as The Comedian, a masked vigilante in a world where masked-justice has been outlawed, Nixon is serving his third term, and the US and USSR are frantically saber-rattling and working to ensure mutual nuclear annihilation. From that point, other characters are introduced as a fellow masked vigilante, Rorschach, investigates what he believes to be a plot to kill those who would stand in the way of a larger plot.
The tone of Watchmen is very dark. It is so dark, in fact, that I doubt too many people will be leaving the theater with a case of the warm-fuzzies. Even The Dark Knight gave viewers a slight lift at the end with the Gordon voice-over ... not the case here. This movie is a very hard R. While the drama can range from decent to heavy-handed, the action scenes are brutal, bloody, and over-the-top graphic. The same can be said for the sexual content, especially with a scene that is closer to softcore porn than anything I've seen in the theater (it's softcore because there's no "money shot"). With that being said, I think it's obvious that this is not a movie for kids. Even if parents didn't mind the graphic scenes, I'd say that most younger audience members would not be able to sit through the exposition which even I found a bit ponderous.
To be honest, that is the flaw of Watchmen ... it is weighed down by the depth of its own narrative. Sure, many characters and arcs have been trimmed from the source material, but there is still a lot of ground to cover. Unfortunately, most of this ground is in the past, meaning a large chunk of the movie is told in flash-back. This may have worked in the novel, but on film, it really starts to feel clunky, especially at the 90-minute mark by which it feels like things still really aren't moving forward yet. The real catch-22 is ... I have no idea how it could have been done any better in a film format.
The acting ranges from cartoony, to bland, to excellent. The standout in a largely unknown cast has to be Jackie Earle Haley who plays a very menacing Rorschach, the most interesting character in both the movie and the novel. I also thought that Jeffrey Dean Morgan put in a good turn as the Comedian, a character killed off before the opening credits but still with a decent amount of screen time (in case you need proof of the copious amount of backstory). Other characters play their roles adequately (though I didn't appreciate "old" Carla Gugino at all) though do little to set themselves apart. The worst "acting" award for the movie probably goes to Richard Nixon's prosthetic nose which, whenever onscreen, is the focal point no matter what else is going on.
So bottom line ... how was it? Well, it is cumbersome, but in the end, I found it a fascinating movie. I'm not exactly sure what the rewatchability factor is, but I'm not sure how a film version of this story could have been improved.
Rating: 7/10
No comments:
Post a Comment