Sunday, March 26, 2006

My review: Crash

Director/screenwriter Paul Haggis's Crash is a story that takes place in a fictional and somewhat convenient Los Angeles. This Los Angeles is evidently populated by about 15 people, some of whom have been painted with Haggis's wide EASY STEREOTYPE brush that he brandished when he penned the roles of Maggie's family in Million Dollar Baby. Over the course of two days, the lives of these people intertwine in various ways and they learn BIG LIFE LESSONS.

I guess that's not a very fair start to a review, so let me start over. Crash is a movie about coincidence and cause and effect. It is a movie where almost everyone is guilty of some form of racism and bigotry. It is a movie where intolerance is paid forward with more intolerance until battles of words or will turn into violence. There is a racist white cop under no illusions about his motivations, and there is a do-good white cop whose actions may cancel out his rational thought or best intentions. There is a black police officer who makes racial jokes aimed at his hispanic partner while he is being pressured to take a make-good position with the district attourney's office. There's the district attourney and his wife, who are robbed by two black men while the men discuss their hurt feelings that they are being racially stereotyped. The list goes on and on, and there is even a hispanic locksmith who ... well, he's the one character who is not portrayed with a fault in the way he views other people.

The truth that Crash tries to get to the heart of is that everyone has preconceived notions about other people. I'm not going to argue with that, as I belive it is part of human nature. Crash also takes the time to show that, while its characters sometimes say and do horrible things to other people, they themselves are still people with their own lives, families, motivations, and dreams. The movie shows both overt and subtle forms of racisim, and it places its characters in situations that do not allow the audience to remain passive. Unsympathetic characters are given moments of sympathy, and sympathetic characters sometimes become monsters. People are people. The cast does a very good job with only a few exceptions.

I guess my biggest complaint about Crash is that its use of coincidence constantly reminded me that I was watching a movie. It constantly reminded me that these people on the screen are not real people, but actors. It sets people up to make revelations about themselves, but only through contrivance. Characters change or see themselves in a new light, but only after a major event. This leaves me asking, what is this movie trying to do? Is it just trying to show me that everybody's a little (or sometimes a lot) prejudiced? Is it trying to show me that there are more racial interactions and tensions than just between white and black? Is it making me question my own beliefs, or does it leave me reacting to what I'm seeing on the screen but not internalizing it?

I know that serious and atrocious racism exists today in America (and across the world). I know that I live a sheltered life here in the midwest, and I know that I have my own preconceived notions and prejudices. I also know that most people are not given such dramatic scenarios that cause them to find themselves as they are given in Crash. My question is, will these characters truly change, or is it only a temporary thing until the shock of the event has worn off?

Perhaps this is just my personality, but I'm more interested in what caused the crash, not the outcome. I'm more interested in the reasons that compel people to be the way they are. This is why I like Spike Lee's Do the Right Thing. It is an unflinching film about racism that deals with many well-drawn characters and their motivations. I'm not saying that Crash is a bad movie ... I think it is far from that. I just think that because of its structure, some generalizability is lost.

The quote that stuck: Well then I guess the big mystery is, who gathered all those remarkably different cultures together and taught them all how to park their cars on their lawns? -- Officer Graham

Rating: 8/10

No comments: