Friday, May 26, 2006

My review: X-men: The Last Stand (X3)

I think the "final" installment of the X-Men movie series will have a fan-base severely divided. The 'Net nerds, who most likely have read all or most of the X-Men comics, have spent the past year on internet forums bitching about how director Bryan Singer has forsaken them for Superman Returns and how Brett "Rush Hour" Ratner may be the biggest hack director ever to walk the planet. The casual viewer of the series, on the other hand, will probably go into this movie knowing very little than what has happened on-screen in the previous two installments. I'm kind of a hybrid of the two groups in that I've read a lot of the bitching (but haven't participated), but the movies are all I know of the X-Men universe.

The first half of the film is spent dealing with the conclusion of X2, in which Dr. Jean Grey sacrifices herself so that the rest of the team can escape Alkalai Lake. Logan (AKA Wolverine) and Scott (AKA Cyclops) are still grieving for the loss of the point of their love triangle. Scott heads to the site of Jean's death, hearing her voice in his head, and witnesses a miraculous resurrection.

Besides this interpersonal plotting, there are some more global happenings of importance. First and foremost, an "antidote" to the mutant gene is developed, offering a "cure" to those who no longer want to be mutants. This leads to a factioning of the mutant community, with some believing this is a good option for those who desire to be rid of their mutation. On the other hand, Magneto and his Brotherhood see this cure as a step to the elimination of mutants, believing what is offered voluntarily now will be forced upon them in the future. The showdown between these factions comes to a boil in the first half of the film and explodes in the last half.

With a runtime of 104 minutes including credits, X3 feels a bit short. It brings up many interesting topics but doesn't really have the time to explore them. There is an interesting moral dynamic to the story, as Magneto definitely has some arguments in his favor in regards to the use of the mutant cure. This aspect of the plot works much better than some of the half-baked love complications given to other characters. The biggest problem, again, is that the film just feels rushed. Several new characters are introduced and given very little time to introduce themselves. Other familiar characters find themselves almost as cameos in a story that doesn't quite know what to do with them.

The acting is about as good and bad as would be expected for a comic book movie. Hugh Jackman's range is not really tested as Wolverine but he inhabits the character well. Patrick Stewart puts in another fine performance as Professor Charles Xavier, but his screen time is limited and his character seems a bit out of tune at times (due to plot, not acting). Halle Barry is still pretty awful as Storm, but after two movies, that was to be expected. Newcomer Kelsey Grammer's Beast is a great addition to the cast. Ian McKellen also turns in another fine performance as Magneto.

As for Brett Ratner's direction, well, if you are looking for stuff to complain about, it was awful. The film has too many quick cuts, the cameras are static or move only in traditional ways, and in general, it is just uninspired and can't hold a candle to Singer's entries. If you go into the film not knowing anything about the new director, however, you probably won't even notice a difference. Nothing in the direction really stood out to me, but nothing really turned me off. Yes, some of the dialogue and character development is horrible, but I'm not sure that can be placed solely on the director. In the end, Ratner does a passable job.

Overall, X3 provides a solid, if somewhat quick, ending to the X-Men trilogy. It is not quite as good as X2, but is probably in a similar league as X-Men. Depending on the box office, I also somehow doubt that this will be the final X-Men movie, though it may be the last one with the current, A-list cast members.

Best special effects: Magneto decides to reposition the Golden Gate Bridge a little

Scene we've seen before (used to effect): Wolverine rushes to attack Magneto, only to be stopped in his tracks

Quote to remember: "I'm the Juggernaut, bitch!"

Rating: 7/10

3 comments:

C the Maven said...

That certainly is a quote to remember . . . a quote worthy of being engraved on the back of a iPod (if and when I ever get one!).

Chris Mong said...

I'm not sure if I want the word "bitch" engraved on anything ... but that's just me. ;)

C the Maven said...

lol