Sunday, June 04, 2006

My review: The Greatest Game Ever Played

The Greatest Game Ever Played is one of Disney's latest "underdog" sports movies. In this film, a young boy from a working-class family strives to become an amateur champion of golf, a sport that, at that time, was almost exclusive to "gentlemen." The story follows young Francis Ouimet and his attempt to both break class divisions and prove to his father that the sport of golf is worthy of Francis's effort. Parallel to Francis's story is that of Harry Vardon, one of the greatest names in golf at the time. Vardon also comes from a lower-class family (only in Britain instead of the US), and even with his fame and championships, he struggles to earn respect from society's upper crust.

This movie starts with the moniker "This is a true story ...." and, truly, it does fit into just about every sports cliche. The main character is an honest, good person who is neglected just because he is not of upper birth. Francis works at a golf course as a caddy but he is not allowed to play or go inside the main building. As luck would have it, he is able to play in the US Open just because it occurs at his course. He is supported by his mother and spends all of his time desperately trying to gain the respect of his father. Francis is attracted (seemingly mutually) to an upper-born girl whose father and brother are determine to keep the two apart. Etc, etc.

Lead actor Shia LaBeouf is probably the most recognizable actor in the movie. He plays his usual unassuming/innocent role that he has perfected over his work in Holes and Constantine. All of the acting is decent, but nothing really stands out. Director Bill Paxton does a serviceable job but doesn't bring too much that is fresh to the table. There are some interesting CGI shots that demonstrate how Vardon is able to remove all distractions while playing, but the effect is overused and, after about the second time seeing it, gets a little boring. There are some scripting/story problems with subtlety and the main points of the film are hammered home again and again. I guess this might be a benefit to a younger audience, but after the first five minutes of the film, YES! I get the fact that golf (at that time and, to a lesser extent now) was full of elitists.

If you've seen one underdog sports movie, you've seen most of them, including this one. I found it enjoyable because I enjoy golf, but a non-fan of the sport may find little to like.

Things that make me question the accuracy of the film: A decent amount of screen time is devoted to the relationship between Francis and Sarah, but there is no followthrough in their story arc and there is no mention of the two in the movie's prologue. This leads me to believe this particular relationship was fabricated/ratcheted to add more class tension.

Quote to remember: Let me tell you something. I came here to win a trophy .... not for England, but for sheer bloody pride at being the best, that's why we do this. And if Mr. Ouimet wins tomorrow, it's because he's the best, because of who he is. Not who his father was, not how much money he's got, because of who he bloody is! And I'll thank you to remember that. And I'll thank you to show the respect a gentleman gives as a matter of course.

Rating (golf fan): 6/10
Rating (non-golf fan): 4/10

No comments: