I've actually been meaning to write more movie reviews. After all, I definitely haven't cut back on the number of movies that I see, though to be honest, most of them are from Netflix instead of theatrical viewings. Forgetting Sarah Marshall, The Brave One, Unbreakable ... I've seen all of these titles recently and had an inkling of writing something about them on my blog. It has taken Tim Burton's Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street to motivate me into writing.
Let's first look at the source material. Sweeney Todd is a second-tier musical written by Stephen Sondheim. I call it second-tier because, while it did play to some success on Broadway, it has had nowhere near the recognition and run of current musical/movies such as Rent, Phantom of the Opera, Chicago, or the upcoming Mama Mia!. The story is dark and bloody ... some may call it a dark comedy, but I never really found enough humor to give it that label. The songs are forgettable and some of them are a mess, though I cannot tell if that is from the source material or the talent behind the movie. In short, this thing was going to be a mess before Tim Burton took control and added in his own blend of "vision" ... ie, gloomy skys; drab, eccentric costumes; wide, pan shots zooming close; and close zooms quickly drawing out into pans. Throw in the questionable singing of Johnny Depp and Helena Bonham Carter, and what you end up with is a hodge podge of gloom, muck, and blood.
The story is quite simple. An evil judge (Alan Rickman) sees a woman he fancies and has her husband (Johnny Depp) arrested and sent to prison. The husband returns years later to have his revenge upon the judge. Nothing too complicated about that, right? Well, there are a few subplots here and there, as well as a few "twists" that are completely obvious. At least for me, it is usually a bad sign in terms of predictability that I can verbally describe, shot for shot, what will happen in the next 30 seconds, and unfortunately this movie was cobbled together with paint-by-number predictability. The only items that stumped me ended up being hanging plot threads, so in my mind, I get a pass on those.
Not only can I not recommend Sweeney Todd, I honestly would have to say that I'd prefer to see the recent, and quite bad, movie version of Rent again repeatedly before watching this pile of dreck again. I understand that Sweeney might be right down some people's alleys, but as someone who is neither a fan of Tim Burton or of the source material, this film does abosutely nothing to make my rethink my position that Sweeney Todd deserves its place in mediocrity and that Tim Burton needs to make a romantic comedy with a pastel color palette in order to convince me he is not a) color blind and b) trying to save money using the same costuming materials and sets.
My rating: 3/10
No comments:
Post a Comment