Saturday, November 01, 2008

My review: Zack and Miri Make a Porno

Let me just start out by saying this ... Zack and Miri is by far the dirtiest movie I've ever seen in the theater. The language is vulgar to the extreme, there is full-full frontal male and female nudity, and some depictions of bodily functions that will stick with you long after the movie is over. The real question is though ... is it funny? My answer ... mostly.

Zack and Miri tells the story of two down-and-out friends/roommates (Seth Rogen and Elizabeth Banks) who have come into hard times, not to mention the threat of their 10-year high school reunion. Throw in an embarrassing YouTube video and turned-off utilities, what you end up with, as one of the characters describes, is the exact situation where someone has to turn to having sex for money. This of course leads to the realization that they could have sex for money, just as long as they didn't ruin their friendship. Thus, writer/director Kevin Smith does something very odd ... he uses pornography as the gateway into a romantic comedy because of course Zack and Miri realize that they have feelings for each other, come across obstacles that keep them apart, and then probably reconcile in the film's closing minutes. What's different in this story is that the "meet-cute" or "moment-of-realization" doesn't happen across the room or in a moment of reflection ... instead it happens during a sex scene. Sure this doesn't sound too sweet, but somehow with music, tight camera angles, and very good performances by both Banks and Rogen, it works.

The cast, as a whole, seems funny and believable for the most part, and while it is obvious that some of the supporting characters really are porn-stars, it also seems equally obvious that the filmmakers would not be able to get anyone else to perform some of the scenes included in this film. Smith's rapid-fire dialogue is still ever-present and, as always, I felt myself wondering if people really talk like that, as the number of f-words and topics of discussion are enough to make a jaded person blush. The saving grace for most of the material, though, is that it is funny, turning what would otherwise be exploitation into acceptable, crude humor. There are a few scenes that I could live without (a naked Jason Mewes bending over to check the refrigerator would definitely be one of them), but the material seemed to hit more than it missed, a difficult feat, especially in my viewing of the film with a whopping three other people in the theater (I think a crowd could only make this type of movie better).

For Smith, this movie seems to be a cross between Mallrats and Jersey Girl ... an attempt at some gross-out, juvenile humor intertwined with a too-sweet romantic comedy. Even though Jay and Silent Bob are absent from the film, there are some other standard Smith-cues, such as some parodying of Star Wars and the inclusion of his wife in the film. Smith seems to have let Rogen have more opportunity for improv than is his usual (as a writer who holds his words above anything else on camera), but most of the improvs seem fairly organic. I also noticed a few camera movements, which I found hilarious as Smith always tries to diffuse criticism about his direction by stating that yes, he knows, static shots are perhaps not the best way to tell a story (but put his dialog on center stage).

In the end, this movie was pretty funny, though for me, it took a few scenes for it to really start clicking. Smith doesn't really ever break any new ground (except maybe what is allowable in an R-rated comedy), but at least he is also not afraid to push the limits instead of reducing it down to try to receive the holy grail PG-13 rating. I'm afraid that this movie will have trouble finding an audience beyond his core fans because, even drawing on Seth Rogen's name, it is probably too crude (especially with "porno" in the title) to draw a standard comedy audience and definitely too crude to draw in a romantic comedy audience. I'd recommend it for anyone who needs a laugh and doesn't mind the crudeness.

Rating: 7/10

No comments: