Monday, May 16, 2005

Film vs. Digital Take 2


Finding Nemo?

I've received some offline feedback that essentially told me that I'd better talk nicer about film or else, so here it goes .... :)

The above picture represents one of my favorite film-based shots, and it was taken using an SLR at the Maui Westin quite a few years ago.

Yes, I took this picture. No Dad, you didn't.

Sorry ... long running family dispute. Anyway, there are several different aspects of the shot that I find interesting. First of all, there is no clear subject to focus on, which kind of freaks the eyes out ... an event not helped by the fact that I don't think the contents of the picture are easily identifiable at first. Second, there is a nice contrast of color and black, which makes the color stand out even more. There is also contrast provided by the leaves floating in the water. Of course, all of these aspects were perfectly and undeniably included by accident. It was the day my family and I were checking out of the hotel and leaving Hawaii, I had some film left, so I used one of my last shots to take a picture of the very pretty fish in the garden outside of the lobby. To be honest, that fish that is partly out-of-frame was probably in-frame when I started to set the picture up, but I might possibly be the slowest SLR user on the planet, and by the time the aperture, speed, and focus were set correctly, several hours had passed. The rest of the composition ... an accident as well. Of course, I didn't know how nice of an accident it was until I got my prints back around a week later.

Anyway, my point is that, using a digital camera, this picture might never have happened (and I know all of the hours consumed years later trying to find the negatives wouldn't have happened, either). Photography, for better or worse, has been changed by the instant gratification of being able to see your pictures the moment you take them ... and yes, I'm ignoring you Polaroid people who were, are, and always will be the ugly step-children of photography. Even if I had gone out to take some pictures of the fish in the pond without needing to spend all of my shots before I could develop them, would I have kept this photo of fish with hardly any fish discernible? I'm not sure that a tiny LCD screen would have shown this photo for the interesting piece that it is, and hence it might have been deleted and replaced with a much more momentarily pleasing, yet pedestrian, picture. Hence the dangers of digital photography: the immediate gratification of viewing shots may also lead to less interesting shots, as the files that may prove the most interesting at a later date don't fit the photographers desires at the instant they are taken. I must admit that there is also a certain level of pleasurable apprehension in ripping open that package of photos you had developed, not really knowing how many shots your finger was in, how many accidently cropped your friend's head off, and how many are truly one-of-a-kind.

The photo below I took during my last vacation using a digital camera (and actually have an 8x10 of it blown up on my wall). My current philosophy of digital is to take as many photos as I want to compose an image, but not to delete any of them until later (unless they are obviously bad .. no flash, etc). In this way, I can capture the way I want my sunset to look, but I also won't lose out on any future fish pictures that truly capture the moment, after the fact.


Sunset in Key West


No comments: