Sunday, May 22, 2005

Politics in mainstream movies: Why strain yourself?

I must say, I'm always amused when a very popular movie is released and certain critics/audience members immediately respond to the film by pointing out all kinds of plot points or imagery that supposedly comments on the politics of today ... Star Wars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith and The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King are two movies that jump immediately to mind. Before their release, political pundits marked them as commentary on today's political landscape.

In Return of the King, the most common political comparison that was drawn was that George W. Bush was Sauron, and that the USA = Mordor. After all, what other country besides is ruled by a ruthless dictator, possesses a dark army capable and desiring of world domination, and is populated by citizens who's only purpose is to aid the war machine and who are expected to obey orders from above with absolute obedience. Similar claims have recently been made with Revenge of the Sith, with George W. Bush being assigned the role of Emperor Palpatine and the US taking the role of the Galactic Empire. While some of the dialogue in Revenge of the Sith may deal indeed have some bearing on today's political climate, I refuse to accept such broad metaphors.

I have no problem with critics or analysts trying to read into movies ... I just wish they wouldn't make such broad claims with little proof. Both The Lord of the Rings and Star Wars existed well before the current administration, and both tap into both dark and light human emotions as a catalyst for their fantasy. The Lord of the Rings was written by J.R.R. Tolkein post-WWII, and though many people look that story for war metaphors (the One Ring = atom bomb, etc), Tolkein repeatedly denied these claims when he was still alive. I guess it's possible that George Lucas modeled Emperor Palpatine after George W. Bush, though the Emperor made his first appearance in Star Wars Episode V: The Empire Strikes Back in 1980 and was more fleshed out as a character in Episode VI: Return of the Jedi in 1983. Even the early machinations of then-Chancellor Palpatine in Episode I: The Phantom Menace in 1999 predate W. Bush's term.

Anyway, I guess my point is that I think that the people who so readily make such comparisons, and believe in them whole-heartedly, do so because they need an excuse to justify their own beliefs or are looking for a way to force their beliefs upon others. Both Star Wars and The Lord of the Rings are popular franchises guaranteed large box office numbers, which is why I think they are used for such pseudo-analysis. There are plenty of movies released that are actually comments on today's politics ... why can't people focus on those? Oh yes ... they are not as popular, that' s why.

No comments: