Critics, even blog ones, always need to be aware of bias in their reviews. That's not to say that criticism can exist without bias as, after all, there is always a personal element to a review. It is what
I think, and while discussion of technical aspects may be filled with true "facts," impact and appeal will always be a matter somewhat steeped in personal opinion. With that in mind, let me mention why I'm bringing this up for my review of
Slumdog Millionaire. Let's face it, after winning an Academy Award for best picture,
Slumdog is no longer the "little picture that could" but is now burdened with the weight of expectation. Expectation placed on it from word-of-mouth is much lighter, in my opinion, than the expectation garnered by winning major awards at Hollywood's annual masturbatory event. The real question is ... will
Slumdog be a movie people will continue to see and talk about, or will it be relegated to the back shelf as one of those "films" people know won awards but don't care too much about seeing, such as last year's best picture winner ... remember what it is? (Hint:
No Country for Old Men)
The first moments of
Slumdog are jarring, disjointed, and confusing. A boy is being tortured, but the reason is unclear. Words are being spoken, but they are soft, non-subtitled, and hard to understand. Images flash around the screen, perhaps memories, and finally ... clues as to what is happening. Our protagonist, Jamal
Malik, is being beaten by police officials because they think he has been cheating on India's version of
Who Wants to be a Millionaire. Evidently he's already progressed quite far or won, the timeline is not sure at this point, but suspicion is cast upon him because "doctors and lawyers" have failed on this show, so how could this boy from the slums know these answers without cheating? When a tape of the show is put in and Jamal is asked to explain how he knew the answers, the structure of the movie is revealed. Jamal's life is shown in flashback, with interludes in the present to move the story forward. This is quite an interesting plot device as not only does it give an excuse for the movie to tell certain tales, but it also removes the game show from being the purpose of the movie. While there is definitely some tension added by the game element, most of the
dramatical moments come from the "three musketeers": Jamal, his older brother Salim, and
Latika, a girl they meet up with who becomes Jamal's obsession.
Slumdog is a movie filled with unknowns (though I suspect a few
Bollywood stars may be involved), meaning that instead of being carried by
starpower, it must be carried by strength of narrative, acting, direction, and the score. All of those points are very strong. All of the actors and actresses are extremely believable and at times this movie felt more like a documentary than a piece of
fiction. This is interesting because Jamal may be the most vanilla, likable character to have graced the screen last year, and yet he never seems like a
caricature. The direction is very solid, and the film is filled with numerous interesting shots and camera movement that solidly gel together. The music is uplifting without being over-intrusive or over-theatrical.
So is it a perfect movie? Well, not quite. At times, I found the pacing to be a bit slow while other times the narrative would make a large jump that would leave me feeling a little confused. I also thought that the "separation" element of the story was used perhaps a little too much. I mean, I get that Jamal is always getting the short end of things, so how many times do we have to keep doing it? I was also, at times, confused about Salim. The character goes through radical shifts that are perhaps slightly too convenient to the plot and desired ending.
In the end,
Slumdog Millionaire is an uplifting, somewhat depressing movie. It is one of those films where you may have a good idea where it is heading, but you are not quite sure if things will turn out the way you expect because these characters exist in a world where good things happen to bad people and bad things happen to good people. Is this the best movie of last year? Probably not. Is it worth watching at least once. Yes.
Rating: 8/10